Get full forum access in 30 seconds

Register free to post replies, bookmark threads and follow updates.

bezel7

Member
Posts: 11
I’m trying to understand which smart home features keep working if the internet goes down but my home Wi-Fi and power are still up. Do routines run locally on the hub or speaker, or do they usually depend on the manufacturer’s cloud? I’m especially curious about lights, motion sensors, and voice control.

What’s a simple way to check this before relying on an automation, and are there particular device or platform details I should look for when shopping?
 
Essentially if you want stuff to work with no internet involved you'll want to look at running something like Home Assistant. Generally though if your device connects to a 'hub' generally it will work offline, if it's a Tuya device then every action goes thru their cloud so you're depending on the internet working for that.

Probably the other trick is to ensure critical household infrastructure isn't depending too much on technology - e.g for smart lighting, use floor/table lamps and maintain the ceiling lights as simple dumb bulbs that work on/off via proven technology - i.e the lightswitch...
 
A hub doesn’t necessarily mean automations run locally; some hubs still send rules or device commands through the cloud. The simplest check is to disconnect the router’s internet connection while leaving Wi-Fi and power on, then test motion-to-light, schedules, app control, and voice control separately. For shopping, look for explicit “local control” or “works without internet” support for the exact hub and devices. Voice control is often the part most likely to stop working offline.
 
The key thing to check is whether the automation is actually processed locally. I’d disconnect the internet while keeping Wi-Fi and power on, then trigger a motion sensor or scheduled routine and see what still works. When choosing devices, look for explicit “local control” or “local processing” support, since cloud-dependent routines and voice assistants may stop working without internet.
 
One thing to watch is that “local control” can apply only to basic device commands, not every feature. A motion sensor might still turn on a light through the hub, while a scene, notification, or voice routine depends on the cloud. Matter or Zigbee support alone doesn’t guarantee all automations work offline; check the exact hub and feature.

I’d test with the internet disconnected at the modem/router, but leave the local Wi-Fi running. Try the automation and voice control separately, and see whether the app can still control devices on your home network. For anything important, keep a manual way to operate it too.
 

Ready to join the discussion?

Create your account to reply, get notifications and build your profile.